[Tricia]

Rebuttal to Judge Julie Carnes’ Decision
Wolfe vs. Ramsey

BROWN BAG AND ROPE



From Judge Carnes’ Decision:

“Specifically, a rope was found inside a brown paper sack in the guest bedroom on the second floor; defendants have indicated that neither of these items belonged to them. (SMF 181; PSMF 181.) Regardless of its ownership, there is no explanation why a bag containing a rope would be in the guest bedroom. Further, small pieces of the material on this brown sack were found in the vacuuming of JonBenet's bed and in the body bag that was used to transport her body (SMF 181; PSMF 181), thereby suggesting that either the bag had been near JonBenet or that someone who had touched the bag had also touched JonBenet. 35”


The Truth

There is no evidence that any of JonBenet’s injuries were caused by the rope that was found inside the brown paper bag, and Judge Carnes’ decision does not mention that the rope found in the bag does not match the cord attached to the garrote. In fact, the ligature found around JonBenet’s neck was described as a white cord material. The only connection one can logically make from the fact there were “small pieces of the material on this brown sack found in the vacuuming of JonBenet’s bed and in the body bag that was used to transport her body” is that JonBenet was at some unknown time in contact with the brown sack or someone who has access to the brown sack (but not necessarily the rope inside the brown sack), since no reference to fibers from the rope inside the brown sack being found on JB is made. The evidence photos prove the rope found inside the brown bag does NOT match the ligature around JonBenet’s neck. One can then also say there is no proven connection between the rope in the brown sack and the murder of JonBenet.

Rope supposedly found in brown bag in the Ramsey guest is pictured with the "Fox News" logo and a ruler. Look at the rope in the picture around JonBenet’s legs. Below the two pictures is a close up of of the picture with the rope around JonBenet’s legs. Could this be where the rope in the bag came from? One of JonBenet’s photo shoots?