Results 1 to 12 of 89
Thread: Handwriting analysis
May 30, 2015, 10:38 am, Sat May 30 10:38:32 UTC 2015 #23
Five point scale for handwriting analysis
1. Conclusive evidence that both are written by the same person
2. Supporting (strong) evidence that they are by the same hand but the possibility of different individuals cannot be ruled out
3. Inconclusive because of equivalent similarities and differences or lack of evidence to work on
4. Supporting evidence that different individuals wrote both the specimen and the questioned writing but the possibility of both being by the same hand cannot be ruled out
5. Conclusive evidence that different individuals were responsible for the specimen and questioned documents
From Lou Smit's deposition we have this verbal description of the handwriting experts' results. Smit's quoting them so I'm going to assume he's accurate:
SMIT: "Chet Ubowski, his results -- and this is a very brief rendition of his results. There were indications that Patsy Ramsey wrote the note. There is evidence which indicates that the ransom note may have been written by Patsy Ramsey. But the evidence falls short of that necessary to support a definite conclusion.
Leonard Speckin, he is a police expert, private forensic document analyst. 'Lack of indications. I can find no evidence that Patsy Ramsey disguised her handwriting exemplars. When I compared the handprinting habits of Patsy Ramsey with those presented in the questioned ransom note, there exists agreement to the extent that some of her individual letter formations and letter combinations do appear in the ransom note. When this agreement is weighed against the number, type, and consistencies of the differences present, I am unable to identify Patsy Ramsey as the author of the questioned ransom note with any degree of certainty. I am, however, unable to eliminate her as the author.'
Edwin Alford, Jr. 'Lack of indications. Examination of the questioned handwriting and comparison of the handwriting specimens submitted has failed to provide a basis for identifying Patsy Ramsey as the writer of the letter.'
Lloyd Cunningham, Ramsey expert, he is the one that certified Chet Ubowski. 'Lack of indications,' that he cannot identify or eliminate Patsy Ramsey as the author of the ransom note. And he has spent 20 hours examining the samples and documents and has found that there were no significant individual characteristics but much significant difference between Patsy's writing and the note.
Richard Dusick, he is the analyst for the United States Secret Service. These are the results of his specific report. 'Lack of indications. A study and comparison of the questioned and specimen writings submitted has resulted in the conclusion that there is no evidence to indicate that Patsy Ramsey executed any of the questioned material appearing on the ransom note.'
Howard Ryle [sic], the former CBI examiner,'probably not.' His opinion in this case is between 'probably not' and 'elimination,' elimination as Patsy Ramsey as the author of the ransom note. He believes that the writer could be identified if historical writings were found.
The results, the general consensus is inconclusive and below that Patsy wrote the note."
Using the description given above, I rate the experts' opinions numerically using the 5 point scale like so:
The majority are "no conclusion," i.e., "inconclusive" as Smit himself says. Maintaining that the experts' opinions could be "collectively described" as 4.5 is simply perverse. When Hunter was asked about "4.5," he said that he remembered it more as being "4," presumably because the 3s can be bumped to 4s. But Speckin is a solid 3 while Alford and Dusick can only, in my opinion, be stretched to 3.5.
By Tricia in forum Justice for JonBenet Discussion - Public ForumReplies: 241Last Post: January 27, 2006, 8:55 am, Fri Jan 27 8:55:17 UTC 2006
By 1000 Sparks in forum Justice for JonBenet Discussion - Public ForumReplies: 21Last Post: January 7, 2005, 5:06 pm, Fri Jan 7 17:06:17 UTC 2005
By "J_R" in forum Laci Denise Rocha PetersonReplies: 1Last Post: July 23, 2004, 4:14 pm, Fri Jul 23 16:14:54 UTC 2004
By JustinCase in forum Justice for JonBenet Discussion - Public ForumReplies: 4Last Post: May 23, 2004, 12:16 pm, Sun May 23 12:16:19 UTC 2004
By Tez in forum Justice for JonBenet Discussion - Public ForumReplies: 64Last Post: January 22, 2004, 9:40 pm, Thu Jan 22 21:40:21 UTC 2004